The Black Ink

How the score works

Every article carries a score from 0 to 100. The AI does not pick that number. It judges the three things below, and we combine them with the same formula every time — so the score is reproducible and checkable rather than a matter of the model's mood.

Nothing below 60 is published here at all.

What the AI judges

Impact (0–10)

How much should a Thai SME owner change what they do because of this?

Urgency (0–10)

How soon does it matter?

Noise (0–10)

How much of this is hype, PR or padding rather than substance? (higher is worse)

The formula

substance = (0.65 x Impact + 0.35 x Urgency) / 10
score     = 100 x substance ^ (1/4) x (1 - 0.45 x Noise / 10)

Impact outweighs urgency because missing a big slow story costs a business more than missing a small fast one. Noise is a multiplier rather than a subtraction: it discounts whatever substance was claimed, so a press release about something genuinely important still can't buy its way onto the front page.

Worked examples

Impact Urgency Noise Score
115 44 A routine item with nothing in it for you — not published
228 43 Press-release filler — not published
333 64 Modest but real -- just clears the floor
542 75 A solid story for one sector
8810 52 Genuinely important, but pure PR -- still not published — not published
880 95 Major and substantive

What the badges mean

The angles we write to

Headlines and summaries are written from the point of view of a Thai SME owner, taking one to three of these angles — the things that reader actually does:

Where this falls short

This is an AI reading a headline and an excerpt, not an editor who knows your business. It misreads things, and judging each component is a decision rather than a measurement — two sensible people would score the same article differently. The formula and the anchors are published above so you can decide how much weight the number deserves, rather than having to take it on trust.

Rubric version: v2-thai-sme